Top Ten Bookish Pet Peeves
Top Ten Tuesday is a weekly meme hosted by the bloggers over at the Broke and the Bookish. Book bloggers from all around create lists based on the chosen topics, and post links to the host blog to share our love of books. This week is a freebie week, which got me all excited. I jumped on this TTT business a little late in the game, so there are oodles of topics I missed that I always want to do. What did I pick? Well, I’m always talking about things that drive me crazy in books, so I thought I’d do at list of my Top Ten Bookish Pet Peeves so I could make a list and vent my negativity. I’ll also be able to link back to this list in future reviews for terrible books, which makes the topic doubly awesome. Here we go…
Top Ten Bookish Pet Peeves
[or things that will drop a book at least one letter grade]
1.) Unnecessary Length – Listen, folks. I’m a very busy lady. It says so in my domain name. I’m fine with long books when they have lots of stuff going on and the length is necessary. But sometimes the little chunky-monkey books could do to lose a few hundred pages and still keep the integrity of the plot. I don’t have all day. If nothing’s happening or I’m bored by a character’s inner dialogue that goes on for multiple chapters, I’m going to be peeved.
2.) Mary Sues – For those who don’t know, a Mary Sue is when the author inserts him/herself as the main character in a novel. This character serves as wish-fullfillment for the author, and is usually annoyingly flawless. That or the character is flawless in a way that isn’t really flawless. Regular fiction doesn’t usually have characters that are 100% Mary Sue, but if the character has enough of this quality, I get peeved.
3.) Cliffhangers – We all know that YA trilogies, especially of the dystopian variety, are guilty of this. I like a book to follow a general plot pattern, with a proper climax and resolution for the main conflict of the story. I’m okay with series cliffhangers or teasers for the overall arc of the big plot, but I want a novel to have an end. Some books are guilty of having no end at all! It’s like a book was split in half/thirds and sold a separate parts. I find this cheap and manipulative and it peeves me.
4.) Kindle Giving Me a % Instead of a Page – This is not related to plot, but it drives me nuts. I like to know what page I’m on, and how many pages are in the book. It’s completely arbitrary, considering some books cram very little or a whole of text on a single page AND considering that e-readers let me set these choices myself, but I want to know how much I’ve read and how much I have left in real number. This is especially annoying on Kindle books that combine multiple books in one…collections, series, etc. I’m reading the Jessica Darling collection now, and I’m in the second book, but only 19% through the series. How much have I read in book 2? How much do I have left? No clue. Peeving.
5.) When Boys Fall For Girls For No Reason – I think I hate this because it gives readers (especially female readers) unrealistic expectations for relationships. The boy saves the girl, tells her she’s beautiful even when she thinks she’s ugly, understands when she lies, worships her from afar, puts up with her rude behavior, etc. How many times can I watch a female character hot-headedly chew out a guy without listening to his side of the story, make assumptions, and give the silent treatment, only to have the guy come crawling back to win her love? Listen, ladies. We need to love ourselves before someone else can love us. We also need respect in a relationship to go both ways.
6.) Mean Librarians – My peeve here is strictly personal. I know some librarians really are mean, but I like to think we are pretty nice, liberal people. I read of stories with nice librarians, but just as many where the librarian is a jerk. And the librarian is almost always a bit character. What’s that about?
7.) When Characters Meet “The One” At Age Sixteen – Very few people end up marrying the person they are dating at age sixteen. I’m glad I’ve spent the past thirteen years dating all kinds of people! Many YA romance plots end with the beginning of the relationship. The characters finally overcome their obstacles, finally get together and commit to each other. But that’s not the end! You know they all break up with they get to college. Wow, I sound really bitter. But I do count this as a major pet peeve.
8.) The Paranormal – (Please don’t hit me). There are exceptions to this: I loved Harry Potter, and I guess the magic element is paranormal. I think it can be done well, but most of it is not to my taste. I don’t know why, but I think it has something to do with me not liking bad boys. I also like my stories to be realistic. I think I only like paranormal elements when the creatures who are vampires/werewolves/ghosts/etc are not main characters in the story, but elements to be overcome or fought against. I recognize that my anti-paranormal thing is a huge bias, so please feel free to recommend a paranormal book that isn’t obnoxious.
9.) Movie Poster Covers – Dear publishers: this is the quickest way to get me to NOT buy a book. I like to think of books as timeless. A good book can be enjoyed years, decades, or centuries after it was written. Regular book covers may date a book (check out ANY 80′s book cover), but a movie book cover will make a book look dated in just a year. It also reminds me that some people are using the movie to sell the book instead of the other way around. Tsk tsk.
10.) Characters With Weird Names – Just pick a normal name for your character, please. Or if one or two characters have to have quirky names, don’t make them be 1.) your main character or 2.) the love interest. It also drives me nuts when many of the characters all have names that start with the same letter, since I think my eyes only catch a few letters when identifying words in the text.
What are your bookish pet peeves?
Posted on July 10, 2012, in books, feminist, librarian, lists, Movies, rants and tagged harry potter, snark, Top Ten Tuesday, why?, ya. Bookmark the permalink. 35 Comments.














This list was really fun to read. I found myself relating to sooooo many
My main pet peeve is one you listed, characters with weird names. It drives me crazy when I can’t pronounce the name.
Funny! I relate most with the Mary Sue peeve, and people falling in love for no reason.
Did you hear me yes-ma’am-ing you throughout this entire list?! Excellent!
Here’s my
Top Ten Books on Happiness. Please stop by!
I agree with so many of these, but my favourite thing that you highlighted, and one that really irks me too, is no.5: boys who fall for girls for no reason. I read a book recently that I thoroughly enjoyed, but in it the main character (a girl) has two boys fall for her, when she’s barely uttered a word to them, and has spent the last however many pages lamenting how ordinary she is. While I am all for female leads realising they’re not ugly/ordinary/etc., I also wish there was something more tangible to explain the boy’s interest. If they haven’t even had a conversation, how is it that he’s suddenly madly in love with her? It seems unrealistic, and I would rather see some realism at the expense of all these together-forever swoonfests, but maybe I’m just being cynical!
Great list, I enjoyed reading it.
I think it just reinforces to teenage girls that they need a boy to save them and to raise their self esteem. But you can’t fall in love with someone else until you fall in love with yourself, and the best way to do that is through experiencing things and having passions.
Most people actually like crazy names for characters, but I think sometimes it is overdone. I agree with you about cliffhangers, too; actually I don’t like cliffhangers even in series, each book should be complete in itself! Great list
I also wish Kindle would give me page numbers… like being 50% of the way through a 600 page book is much different than being 50% of the way through a 200 page book. I also never realized how often I look ahead to see when a chapter is going to end until I got a Kindle and I can’t just stick my finger in the book to hold my place while I look ahead…
Exactly! Sometimes I’m waiting for a book to end, and sometimes I don’t ever want it to end…but I like knowing how far I’ve read and how much I have to go. Darn it, Kindle!
Okay, well I have become engrossed in many paranormal series and I guess the reason is for the great escape but I also enjoy a good sci-fi novel as well. I use to love mysteries and many others but then when following an author the books became formula-matic and it just wasn’t as thrilling anymore. I would say try Sherrilyn Kenyon and her League series it paranormal/sci-fi she has other series that are good to like the Dark Hunter series. My absoulte favorite author/book series is JR Ward in the Black Dagger Botherhood series. However, be prepared they are very steamy and adult, however her writing is just amazing and I love her sense of characters. Also some crazy character names but I think they are quite awesome for the crazy stories, fitting in some nutty way that at some point you just go with it and appreciate them
I do have those moments as you mention in other books I’ve read where I go, really that’s their name?
Last thought – yes Kindle needs page numbers and a friend of mine indicated there is a way to change this but I have yet to figure it out – someone help all of us here!!
Thank you for the recommendations! I’ll look into those. I need to broaden my horizons, you know?
OMG YESSS. All of these. I cannot stand movie poster covers. I also can’t stand books that are long and rambly with NO point, like okay I don’t mind long books as long as there is a point to it.
I do like PNR though.
OH OH and cliffhangers and weird names totally get my goat. So annoying.
My TTT
I agree with most of your list! The boys falling for girls for no reason thing really bothers me, too! Also, I’m with you on the paranormal thing. I used to think I just didn’t like fantasy, but then I realized that all my favorite books were fantasy, so that couldn’t be it. I think I like magic, just not magical creatures – dragons, werewolves, vampires, etc (except Remus Lupin). The only other series I like with a lot of demons/vampires/werewolves is the Dresen Files series by Jim Butcher, and I think that’s because for the most part it’s about a wizard who has to fight those creatures, and I enjoy those books more than books about vampires. Also because the vampires/werewolves in his novel aren’t main characters. That helps, I think.
Love your TTT topic! I’m nodding with all of these. How hard can it be for Amazon to figure out page numbers?? And I’ve had very positive interactions with librarian’s so I’m not sure why they are misrepresented so often. And the dreaded movie poster cover- ugh!
Great list of pet peeves! I never thought about it, but I don’t like movie covers either. the kindle percentage drives me crazy, too. What is so hard about putting a page number in? Find “the one” at age sixteen makes me roll my eyes, too.
I’m with you on #7! I think that is one of my biggest complaints about YA romance.
My bookish pet peeves are the current fad for “urban adult fantasy” and paranormal lovers alternately taunting and comforting each other! What is THAT about? And what is up with all these middle-aged church ladies going nuts over 50 Shades of Grey? How hypocritical is that!
AH! The percentage on the kindle is so frustrating. I wish there was an option for page numbers instead.
Top Ten: Favorite Declarations of Love in YA
Great list! I agree with basically every peeve of yours; I’ve especially noticed the cliffhanger one a lot recently. Coupled with the fact that it seems like more series are being produced these days than standalones, it’s very frustrating. I consider myself a pretty particular reader, and another peeve of mine is reading a used book that has clearly been used, with stains, rips, highlights, and bent pages. I like my books pristine.
Five and Seven. So much! It’s just unbearable! And weird names? You mean like Renesmee-weird or just normal-weird?
Patricia // My Post
Oh gosh! I HATE movie posters as book covers! Especially if the movie has just come out and I haven’t gotten to read the book yet and I start reading it. Nothing looks worse to me than looking like I’m only reading a book because the movie is out! Great list!
I also hate movie posters as book covers. I’m so glad that other people hat that too. I also hate #4. Why give me a percentage? Definitely annoys me.
Great list!
Here’s mine
~Danica Page
P.S. If you stop by be sure to check out my giveaway for any book under $15.
I agree with almost all of these (I don’t mind the paranormal). I will put a book down quickly if it isn’t written well or if the “plot” leaves me floundering.
And I am right there with you on the e-reader percent point…I have a Nook, and I got the first 4 books of the Game of Thrones series as a bundle with a gift card. I know I’m in book 4 now, but in the middle it was “okay, I’m on page 1875 out of 3525, where the eff am I in this book!?” It’s odd to not know where I am concretely in a given book.
Great list!
I agree with most of your list, but I find the movie poster covers really annoying. I’m with you on the e-reader thing, and it’s weird not knowing where I am when I’m reading.
I laughed my way through this!! My thoughts exactly! Except I secretly like paranormal and do want to hit you.
I am with you on SO many of these although I do love my paranormal reads and weird named characters!
Marissa
here’s my TTT
I agree with this so much! I absolutely hate movie poster covers. They make the original book seem like a mere second thought. Cliffhangers annoy me too. It feels like the author chose the easy way out.
I completely agree with #4. So dang frustrating.
Agree, agree, agree! I think #5 and #7 are a big reason why I only like *some* YA. And I wish Kindle would give us a page number or percentage option. Oh, and movie poster covers? When I see someone with those, I always think they only picked it up because they saw it on the way to the checkout counter at the grocery store and they may have seen the movie and probably aren’t big readers. Do I sound like a book snob?
As a fellow Library worker (not a Librarian but a Library technician working as a Library Assistant…confusing I know but I digress…) I get annoyed at misrepresented Librarians too – in movies and TV shows as well as books! The grumpy Librarian wearing her hair in a stern bun, wearing a musty cardigan and peering at you through glasses balanced on the end of her pointy nose? So not relevant anymore! But what also annoys me is when a character needs to research something, they go to the library and ask the Librarian and she pulls the exact right book out from behind the desk! What?!
Love the whole list but that peeve in particular resonated
I love this list! I agree with 9/10 things on it. Most especially #5, that’s always confused me.
Number 7 is a great one. Though you can see page numbers on some books on the Kindle now, if you press menu whilst reading, the page number appears at the bottom next to the percentage if it’s available. It tells you on Amazon whether a book has page numbers available and I believe they’re trying to introduce them to all books.
I agree with you about the Mary Sues, A lot of people think the main Character in my books are me just because they have red hair, (I like red heads) but they are actually totally different if you get to know me, The only similarity is in the first book she was sarcastic, other than that there is nothing to link me to the character and I hate people thinking that,
The movie poster one! That is the worst! Buying/reading a book with the movie poster cover shows that you are only reading the book because it is going to be a movie. And don’t try to say that you were a fan of the story before it became a movie. I’m not one to bash on people for reading, whatever their motivation may be. But don’t pretend like you are a hardcore, life-long fan because you read the book a month before the movie came out. Amazing list, by the way!
A nice list you have here! I totally agree with most of your points, it really annoys me! Cliffhangers can get very annoying especially when sometimes they are pretty cliché as well. Mary Sues are annoying but they can get toned down (if you tell the writer). By the way, I wrote a post about my own fiction pet peeves on my blog so I hope you will read and comment with your own opinion telling me what you think! http://nynyonlinex.wordpress.com/2013/03/06/fiction-pet-peeves/
Pingback: Envy « The Librarian Who Doesn't Say "Shhh"